Extensive reading (ER) provides learners with opportunities to read for enjoyment and develop reading skills without formal assessments This study investigates factors influencing both motivation or the reasons students choose to read and engagement or how actively they participate in a weekly graded reading program involving 52 university students in a critical reading class. Using surveys and semi-structured interviews, the study explores students' experiences, challenges, and perceived benefits of ER. Findings reveal key motivators that sustain participation, as well as obstacles that may hinder engagement. The session offers insights into how ER activities can foster student engagement and potentially increase the amount of reading they do. Attendees will gain practical recommendations for implementing ER in similar educational contexts and strategies to encourage students to read more through meaningful engagement.